Possible neoliberal connotations in Brave New World
1. Huxley and Negative Dialectics
It seems clear that Aldous Huxley was a forerunner who would foreshadow post-modern social science fiction, speculative literature and post-modernism in general. By that time, the 1930s, ideologies like neo-Marxism (Frankfurt school for instance; Adorno and Horkheimer with their Dialektik der Aufklärung, which was published in 1944 but whose ideas had been around for about fifteen, twenty years) were shifting the emphasis from synthesis to antithesis in the Hegelian paradigm. This change in the point of view to analyse the Hegelian triad was rooted in the rise of Nazism, Stalinism, capitalism and mass culture. In Huxley, this negative dialectics that would be the main reason for his omen of post-modernism, appears to be rooted in contempt towards a class of progressive intellectuals, the naïve utopian socialists, and H.G. Wells in particular; “as he once wrote to his brother Julian, ‘all’s well that ends Wells’” (Firchow 278), “Nor did Huxley take any special pains to hide the fact that in Brave New World he was, among other things, blasting Wells” (Firchow 260), more than his work being rooted in questioning western social conventions which would be the origin of certain 20th century horrors. First, he did not seem to be a great admirer of the aesthetic representations in this movement that questioned old conventional norms and the rigid system of values of Realism; “given distractions such as jazz recordings and the gramophone, many people would ‘go through life with the intellectual development of boys and girls of fifteen’ (…) Huxley damns Ulysses as ‘one of the dullest books ever written, and one of the least significant’” (Meckier 236) or talking about the introduction of sound in cinema “Huxley condemns the talkies as ‘the latest and most frightful creation-saving device for the production of standardized amusement’” (Frost 443) being it the media in which Buñuel, Renoir or Orson Welles would create their masterpieces.
In Huxley’s own words and with pejorative tone, «the modern artist seems to have grown down; he has reverted to the preoccupation of his childhood. He is trying to be a primitive” (Firchow 274). The author of Brave New World obviously had a different criterion than other authors and movements that dealt with negative dialectics concerning politics, society and aesthetics. For instance, for neo-Marxists (who articulated Marx and Freud theories, generally speaking) and post-modernists (decades later of course) would be a central matter to question conventions and universals such as the canon and the works that form it or why are those are an integral parts, while Huxley talks about how “only a new Shakespeare- and pointedly, not H.G. Wells- can rescue a ‘steadily decaying civilization’” (Meckier 236). In this almost messianic idea, it seems clear how his ideologically marked discourse and his critical perspective often lay on an emotional and not intellectual basis. Maybe, his impressive vision of a future society comes from these devastating forces that taint it with a strong ideological direction at the same time, or, in other words, his simplistic plot, cynical violence and manichaean main character (John the savage) disguised in a chosen literary genre, satire, are symptoms of an incipient neo-Liberalism, in which everything can be bought and sold… As Huxley says, mocking progressive ideologies and modernist aesthetic representations, “whereas Rousseau’s savage was noble, refined and intelligent, the primitive our modern artists would like to resemble is a mixture between the Apache and the fifteen-year old schoolboy» (Firchow 274). That is a very cynical statement in which he uses Rousseau to attack progressive thinking, everything can be bought and sold as I said before.
2. Neo Liberal Myth: Brave New World vs Reservation; Eastern Spirituality and Western Materialism
A society controlled by means of eugenics and conditioned by means of hypnopaedia is one that assumes the necessity of regulation and, in Brave New World, the bad consequences of such conditioning are underlined. On the other hand, the reservation is a society unaware of regulation, a marked regulation or hierarchy that in fact exists by means of cultural conventions (the role of men and women in society, religion, a very marked language, rites of initiation and manhood…). A clear example of this is when Linda, mother of John the Savage and ex-citizen of the brave new world, is cursed and treated like a prostitute because of having sex with several men of the reservation and especially with Pope, a local. Men, there, have a sexual freedom unthinkable for a woman, unlike in Brave New World´s London where women and men are equal in rights and have the freedom to choose, deny and change. In this sense, a conscious regulation is necessary for the equality of rights. However, a society regulated by conventions, which have been built by part of it, to its own image (men and white in this case), has a helplessness only comprehensible for the ones (e.g. readers of this paper) belonging to those oppressed groups (women for instance). Myths are “the truisms of our culture” (Larsen 506) and they “are generated in the face of a conflict experienced subconsciously as a binary opposition” (Larsen 506). The binary opposition between both societies could be interpreted as a satiric device; satire is the genre Huxley uses to express his ideas in Brave New World and this genre is also based in this kind of opposition. However, it could be interpreted as the binary opposition generating a myth, a cynical weapon commonly used by neoliberals to undermine politics and social justice. For neoliberals, nothing is worthy of consideration, politics is useless idealism, but they have the money and since politics is controlling inequality and social justice they make it synonymous of corruption and the greatest evil of all, and this way they control it all… “If a given mythology confers prominence on a certain figure, let us say an evil grandmother, it will be claimed that in such a society grandmothers are actually evil and that mythology reflects the social structure and the social relations” (Levi-Strauss 429). The contrast between the brave new world and the reservation symbolizes Huxley´s idea of opposition between “Eastern spirituality and Western materialism” (Meckier 237). The myth of a conflict between civilizations is a very cynical idea in which politics are mutilated, a clear ideological position and common neoliberal discourse rooted in Huxley’s anti-Marxist obsession. If certain countries are highly religious it is because of poverty and not nature. Huxley finds a place in his imaginarium for such opposition; H.G. Wells versus D. H. Lawrence, utopian Socialism versus mysticism; “When Lawrentian outlook and Wellesian forecast collide, each makes the other appear absurdly incomplete” (Meckier 237). All this is clearly seen in the opposition between what Peter M. Larsen calls “Synthetic Myths” and certain traditions of the reservation. “Synthetic myths” are Brave new world´s “jingles, rewritten nursery rhymes, rewritten proverbs, new proverbs and pseudostatements” (Larsen 507), standardized morals (as everything in the brave new world) which seem to have lost their essence and direct meaning (“…meaningless rhythmic repetition, and so on in keeping with the infantile emotionalism of society in 632 AF” (Larsen 507) “Ending is better than mending” (Brave New World 50), “Ford helps to those who help themselves”(Brave New World 168), “Progress is lovely” (Brave New World 85)… ). These “Synthetic Myths” seem to have lost contact with ethics, the original function of a litany. Now, their only motivation is the control over people; materialism. However, the rites and conventions of the reservation (rituals of manhood for instance) are doted of a particular authenticity, they still keep part of their essence because of its mysticism. This way, the biased logic of Huxley’s creation is exposed in his idea of conflict between civilizations; where a different civilization means a different nature, and where being a rich or a poor country makes no difference.
3. Old Conventions (John the Savage and a Traditional Narrative) to Criticise New Conditionings (Intervention of the State): Neoliberal Manichaeism
In Brave New World, a novel of ideas and “a book about the future” (Huxley), Huxley uses certain narrative devices with ideological purposes, and also in order to attract audiences; “For the sake, however, of dramatic effect, the Savage is often permitted to speak more rationally than his upbringing among the practitioners of a religion that is half fertility cult and half Penitente ferocity would actually warrant. Even his acquaintance with Shakespeare would not in reality justify such utterances” (Huxley). The fact that John the Savage understands a kind of “universal sensibility” coming from a completely different background just by means of reading Shakespeare is clearly biased… could William Shakespeare be isolated from the rituals and hierarchies of our society? When a category is universalized and isolated from the background where it has been created, it gets dangerously marked ideologically speaking because what is not included in this universal definition is neglected (e.g. particularities, differences…).
Brave New world´s first part is multi-layered and complex. There, Huxlex describes a world in which a projection towards the future of certain communist and capitalist ideas shows the stupidity and dangerousness of its execution, the dangerousness of the perpetuation of some extreme policies and utopian ideologies so to say. He does it without using neither any kind of manichean plot, nor satire itself, the genre, as a mean to neglect politics. The ideas on eugenics, conditioning, and a completely new sensibility are brilliantly exposed. Everything works well until the character of John the “noble” Savage appears in the reservation. Then, the binary opposition between the brave new world and the reservation (conditioning versus convention) is tainted by this idea of a universal consciousness, an ultimate truth achieved by William Shakespeare among others. The idea of such a manichean concept of human nature, clearly defined outside the rules of our society, outside politics, turns the satire or novel of ideas into a sort of pamphlet in which human nature is a universal that does not have any connection to politics (fact that does not have anything to do with Shakespeare, who really deals with politics in his work; who can have an existential doubt but Hamlet, a prince– Shakespeare was alway a very political playwright). And then, (ironically speaking) being violence and “natural” traditions the true regulators of society, why do we need the intervention of the state to regulate inequality when this is totalitarian? is it not imposing certain conditions? Well, this is one of the problems of arguing against a neoliberal ideology, in which everything is simplified and easily categorized, in which everything seems to respond to some kind of “common sense”… For instance, to give opinion about economics is easy but to really understand it you need to be a specialist and that is the way things work in human society (every science has its own language and method and nothing is so easy as a universal common sense that can answer everything). Certain intervention of the state is a necessary regulation, it is developed by particular disciplines and it cannot be lightly judged.
The same thing happens with the use of violence at the end of the novel, when John the Savage flagellates and hits Lenina in the middle of an orgy-porgy. Violence seems to be a patriarchal science-fiction convention which explains how human nature is violence-based and how this is a taboo in society. Violence is one of the forming categories of the human being and its society but neither more nor less important than others. The point here is not that violence is a taboo in society, because it is not, but the fact that ultra-violence is shocking, the same as other “ultra-categories” in popular media. However, ultra-violence and ultra-sex seem to be synonymous of freedom in the archetypical adolescent mind of men in our society. Ironically, Huxley cynically forgets the violence towards the female character, Lenina, in his introduction to 1947´s version of Brave New world, centring all the attention on John´s action and emotional journey, neglecting women ideas and other perspectives on such matters (Huxley neglects violence against women as insubstantial compared to man´s suffering and his initiation journeys) “And at the close, of course, he is made to retreat from sanity; his native Penitente-ism reasserts its authority and he ends in maniacal self-torture and despairing suicide. “And so they died miserably ever after”–much to the reassurance of the amused, Pyrrhonic aesthete who was the author of the fable.” (Huxley)
As it has been discussed, Huxley makes use of certain conventions, like marked narrative devices or ideological discourses, to criticise state interventionism in a clear attempt to distort politics. He does it in a very similar way in which media does it nowadays, with a relentless discourse of cynicism and populism; Neo-liberalism.