Bibliography

Posted in Shakespeare's comedies on diciembre 9th, 2012 by pasla

Bean, John C. “Comic Structure and the Humanizing of Kate in The Taming of the Shrew.” The Woman’s Part; Feminist Criticism of Shakespeare. Urbana: University of Illinois, 1980. 65-78.

Delahoyde, Michael. The Comedy of Errors. Washington State University. 2011. Website ( http://public.wsu.edu/~delahoyd/shakespeare/comedyerrors2.html)

Furstnau, Erin. Feminist Themes in and Critiques of Shakespeare’s Taming of the Shrew. Cedar Crest College Website (http://www2.cedarcrest.edu/academic/eng/lfletcher/shrew/efurstnau.htm)

Kehler, Dorothea. “Echoes of the Induction in The Taming of the Shrew.” Renaissance Papers 1986. 31-42.

Kolin, Philip C. «Shakespeare and Feminist Criticism» Garland Publishing: New York, 1991.

Shakespeare, William. «A Midsummer Night’s Dream». The Complete Works of William Shakespeare. Wordsworth Editions: Oxford, 1996. Printed

Shakespeare, William. «The Comedy of Errors«. The Complete Works of William Shakespeare. Wordsworth Editions: Oxford, 1996. Printed

Shakespeare, William. «The Taming of the Shrew». The Complete Works of William Shakespeare. Wordsworth Editions: Oxford, 1996. Printed

Sparknotes.com (Sparknotes.com)

Squyer, Emily. The Feminist Subtext of Shakespeare’s Leading Ladies. Washington State University. 2011. Website ( public.wsu.edu/~delahoyd/shakespeare/sample5.html)

Tennenhouse, Leonard. Power on Display: the Politics of Shakespeare’s Genres. New York: Methuen, Inc., 1986. 73–76.

Wikipedia.org (Wikipedia.org)

Conclusion

Posted in Shakespeare's comedies on diciembre 9th, 2012 by pasla

As a conclusion, the feminist study of the three plays shows how complex is Shakespeare’s work. To draw a clear conclusion is really difficult ever since every element in the Bard’s plays is so rich and meaningful. For instance, Katherina, “the shrew” in The Taming of the Shrew, can be seen as the perfect example of how a rebel woman should be “tamed” following a patriarchal logic. On the contrary, the way Shakespeare puts it all  together (the explicit and constant bullying of Petruchio on Katherine or her last words in the play) is a way to expose how the patriarchy really works. When I think about Katherina’s last speech which is utter patriarchal propaganda, I cannot help thinking about Alex, the protagonist in Kubrick’s The Clockwork Orange (filmic adaptation of Anthony Burgess novella). Alex undergoes the experimental Ludovico Technique (bullying) imposed by the government. The technique is so institutionalised as the patriarchy itself. After the treatment, Alex mechanically delivers an apology of the institutional values. Kate’s “taming” process could be seen in this manner, as a denouncement of the violence of the patriarchal system.

In Midsummer Night’s Dream, the juxtaposition of two worlds, the real world of Athens and the woods of the fairies, exposes a patriarchal system of values in which “Amazon warriors, possessive mothers, unruly wives, and willful daughters are brought under the control of lords and husbands» (Montrose). Hippolyta, the queen of the Amazons, is under Theseus authority in Athens, the world which Hermia flees in order to escape her father’s control which neglects her. Hermia goes deep into the unruling woods where she chooses for herself. On the other hand, some feminist criticism could object that she runs away to be the possession of another man, Lysander. However, the idea that the patriarchy is so deeply rooted in our culture that it even penetrates the unconscious can be argued here. The patriarchal influence is felt even there, into the woods. This way, Shakespeare would have portrayed how difficult is to avoid the patriarchal conventions that constitute our society. Even for this person (Hermia) who is an individual with the will to break those laws, it is impossible to break completely free because she (Hermia in this case) is what she is because of these very same laws.
And finally, in The Comedy of Errors, the two different perspectives about marriage, Luciana and Adriana’s, are not a simple contrast of viewpoints, since none of them stands for a clearly differentiated position; the feminist and antifeminist seem to be the two opposing archetypes at the beginning of the play. However, they evolve into more complex characters. Adriana seems to be the archetypical “shrew” but she turns out into a more fleshed out character. Also, Luciana seems to stand for the patriarchal values but she refuses to get marry for a long time, and this is the way by which women are objectified in society; being the wife of a MAN. Luciana rejects patriarchal ideology this way although in the end she marries Antipholus of Syracuse, but only after acknowledging that he is not her sister’s husband. Adriana, a woman, is a priority for Luciana.
To sum up, I think that the ideology of Shakespeare concerning women in society was quite progressive. He portrayed female characters with complex personalities in complex situations. However, he wrote flat women too but he also did it with male characters. From my point of view, he denounced injustice in Elizabethan society by means of exposing its hypocrite and rigidly fixed patriarchy. Finally, and quoting Emily Squyer “Queen Elizabeth I certainly influenced many of Shakespeare’s plays and characters and he may have become more feminist due to his desire to please her. The general public may also have preferred strength in female characters as a reflection of pride for their beloved monarch who was one of the few highly competent English rulers in spite of her gender and the sexism of the time in which she lived”

Two different perspectives about marriage in The Comedy of Errors

Posted in Shakespeare's comedies on diciembre 9th, 2012 by pasla

In The Comedy of Errors, I will discuss the two sisters, Adriana and Luciana, and their two different perspectives about marriage. Firstly, Adriana is E. Antipholus’ wife and shares some features of the shrewish archetype (jealous and vicious) although she is a not a character so flat, she is a more fully fleshed out woman who is obsessed with her husband cuckolding her (shmoop.com). In this manner, she questions some patriarchal conventions such as the man, the husband, having more freedom and independence in marriage than his wife; the subordination of woman in marriage so to say. When she talks with her sister, Luciana, afraid that Antipholus of Ephesus loves another woman
(Delahoyde):

“Why should their [men’s] liberty than our be more?” (Act II, scene 1, line 10)

To what Luciana answers her from a completely different conception of marriage, a conception that comes from having no experience on the matter:

“Because their business still lies out o’door” (Act II, scene 1, line 11)

Luciana is not married to any man, and then, she idealises the patriarchal institution of marriage because she has never experienced it. She glorifies the social categories of husband and wife which make up the public world the man’s sphere, and women’s the private one. In the next passage, Luciana’s patriarchal ideas are clearly delivered:

“Why, headstrong liberty is lash’d with woe.
There’s nothing situate under heaven’s eye
But hath his bound, in earth, in sea, in sky:
The beasts, the fishes, and the winged fowls,
Are their males’subjects and at their controls:
Men, more divine, the masters of all these,
Lords of the wide world and wild watery seas,
Indued with intellectual sense and souls,
Of more pre-eminence than fish and fowls,
Are masters to their females, and their lords:
Then let your will attend on their accords.”

(Act I, scene 1, lines 15-25)

Luciana seems to be supporting the hierarchy in which women are below men. However, this is not so so simple in The Comedy of Errors, Luciana is a character who has renounced to get married for a long time, and she has rejected the patriarchal establishment this way. The system tended to neglect women by objectifying them, by means of categorizing them as wives; «In Shakespeare’s age, a married woman was ‘no person,’ or someone without status» (Kolin 15).

«Male Dominance» in Midsummer Night’s Dream

Posted in Shakespeare's comedies on diciembre 9th, 2012 by pasla

In A Midsummer night’s Dream, male dominance (wikipedia) is an important thematic element to analyze from a feminist point of view. The patriarchal power stands out over individual freedom, and over women in particular. In this manner, Egeus talks about his daughter Hermia when asks Theseus to force her to marry Demetrius:

«As she is mine, I may dispose of her:
Which shall be either to this gentleman
Or to her death, according to our law»

(Act I, Scene 1, lines 42-44)

This is a clear example of the conflict between the patriarchy and the individual throughout the play, and most particularly between the patriarchal hierarchy and women; male dominance so to say. Here, being the father, which includes being a man, confers authority. Also, Egeus wants to give his possession, Hermia, to another man, her would-be husband Demetrius, who would be the man who will posses her from then on. Passing the “possession” (woman) from man to man:

“In his article, «The Imperial Votaress», Louis Montrose draws attention to male and female gender roles and norms present in the comedy in connection with Elizabethan culture. In reference to the triple wedding, he says, «The festive conclusion in A Midsummer Night’s Dream depends upon the success of a process by which the feminine pride and power manifested in Amazon warriors, possessive mothers, unruly wives, and wilful daughters are brought under the control of lords and husbands.» (Wikipedia)

Another example of this rigid system would be Helena addressing her beloved but not corresponding Demetrius. This time is the other way around because the woman accepts her submissive role:

“I am your spaniel; and Demetrius,
The more you beat me, I will fawn on you:
Use me but as your spaniel, spurn me, strike me,
Neglect me, lose me; only give me leave,
Unworthy as I am to follow you.”

(Act II, scene 1, lines 203-207)

On the contrary, «authority gone archaic» (Tennenhouse 73) is the problem in the play. The law in Athens requires the death of the daughter for disobeying her father’s will and it feels obsolete when compared to the disordered world of the fairies; Oberon’s world.
Tennenhouse asserts that male power disappears in carnival time in the woods. For instance, everything involving the four lovers in the forest is chaotic, however, there is no punishment for it, whatever happens in the woods is outside the patriarchal laws.
The contrast between the forest and Athens clearly shows how rigid and unfair Theseus patriarchy (Athens) really is because it unveils how fathers, husbands and men in general treat inferior beings in the patriarchal hierarchy as mere possessions. In the next extract, Theseus defines Hermia, her body, her mind, her being… because that is what patriarchy does, it gives shape to everything. In this point in the play, she is her father’s possession, nothing more, and he wants her to be Demetrius’ in spite of her will to be Lysander’s lover and wife.

THESEUS
“What say you, Hermia? be advised fair maid:
To you your father should be as a god;
One that composed your beauties, yea, and one
To whom you are but as a form in wax
By him imprinted and within his power
To leave the figure or disfigure it.
Demetrius is a worthy gentleman.”

(Act I, Scene 1, lines 50-56)

Katherina’s “taming” in The Taming of the Shrew

Posted in Shakespeare's comedies on diciembre 9th, 2012 by pasla

In The Taming of the Shrew, Katherina would be the female character to discuss from a gender perspective. She is a strong, ill-tempered woman (the “Shrew” in the play) who marries Petruchio. Petruchio transforms Katherina into an obedient and proper woman, according to the patriarchal standards, by bullying her. She is “tamed” this way. The audience sees how the strong woman who confronts Petruchio with such tremendous duel of words,

KATHERINA
If I be waspish, best beware my sting.
PETRUCHIO
My remedy is then, to pluck it out.
KATHERINA
Ay, if the fool could find it where it lies,
PETRUCHIO
Who knows not where a wasp does
wear his sting? In his tail.
KATHERINA
In his tongue.
PETRUCHIO
Whose tongue?
KATHERINA
Yours, if you talk of tails: and so farewell.
PETRUCHIO
What, with my tongue in your tail? nay, come again,
Good Kate; I am a gentleman.
KATHERINA
That I’ll try.
She strikes him
PETRUCHIO
I swear I’ll cuff you, if you strike again.
KATHERINA
So may you lose your arms:
If you strike me, you are no gentleman;
And if no gentleman, why then no arms.

(Act II, scene 1, lines 210-223)

this vicious Katherina, turns into a docile lady, loyal advocate of the patriarchal system of values in which she is under her husband’s utter command. The next lines are part of Katherina last words in the play which clearly expose the character’s change

Thy husband is thy lord, thy life, thy keeper,
Thy head, thy sovereign; one that cares for thee,
And for thy maintenance commits his body
To painful labour both by sea and land,
To watch the night in storms, the day in cold,
Whilst thou liest warm at home, secure and safe;
And craves no other tribute at thy hands
But love, fair looks and true obedience;
Too little payment for so great a debt.

…

Why are our bodies soft and weak and smooth,
Unapt to toil and trouble in the world,
But that our soft conditions and our hearts
Should well agree with our external parts?

(Act V, scene 2, lines 169–172)

Here, Kate not only advises women to be obedient to their husbands but she also marks women as physically pusillanimous beings, and then, infers that women should match their physical weakness with psychical mildness; Katherina “stereotypes women as physically weak and then suggests that they should make their personality mild to match their physique” (Sparknotes).

Katherina and her “taming” have been study objects for many critical perspectives (Furstnau). For instance, John C. Bean argues that Shakespeare was not a misogynist since he humanizes Katherina, a female character,  in a genre (farce) in which characters are plain stereotypes:

“What we should emphasized in The Taming of the Shrew is the emergence of a humanized heroine against the background of depersonalizing farce…

…

Since farce treats persons as if they lacked the sensitivities of an inward self, that genre is appropriate to a view of marriage in which the wife is mainly the husband’s chattel. But Shakespeare’s romantic comedy is concerned with the discovery of the inward self, with love as personal, and hence with the relationship of lovers who face together the problem of reconciling liberty and commitment in marriage.” (Bean 66)

John C. Bean also says in his “Comic Structure and the Humanizing of Kate in The Taming of the Shrew” that it would be a mistake to label Shakespeare as a chauvinist playwright because what strikes modern audiences as misogynist ideas could have been normal in Shakespeare’s times:

“If we can appreciate the liberal element of Kate’s last speech–the speech that strikes modern sensibilities as advocating male tyranny–we can perhaps see that Kate is tamed not in the automatic manner of behavioral psychology but in the spontaneous manner of the later romantic comedies where characters lose themselves in chaos and emerge, as if from a dream, liberated into the bonds of love.” (Bean 66)

On the contrary, the dark humor in the play can convey an awkward feeling to audiences nowadays, as Petruccio’s bullying Kate is a grotesque image that cannot be ignored. Misogyny and patriarchal violence are truly present in the play from nowadays perspective and it is quite shocking to see Petruchio’s “taming” Kate, not letting her eat or sleep or to make her say:

“Forward, I pray, since we have come so far,
And be it moon, or sun, or what you please:
An if you please to call it a rush-candle,
Henceforth I vow it shall be so for me.”

(Act IV, scene 5, lines 12-15))

Dorothea Kehler’s feminist approach would argue that this is not a question of contextualization; it is not just awkward in the eyes of modern audiences but men were who wrote and performed mainstream plays in Elizabethan England and male sensibility and ideas are what mark Shakespeare’s The Taming of the Shrew:

“The explicit and implicit subjects of this play–arranged marriages, the authority of fathers and husbands, the obedience expected from daughters and wives, the economic helplessness of most women–were issues and experiences that touched the lives of everyone in Shakespeare’s audience. While modern interpreters may see Shrew as a high-spirited comedy about role-playing of game-playing, they suppress the knowledge that men, not only on stage, but off, wrote the play and assigned the roles, chose the game and made the rules.” (Kehler 31)

Also, the attributes which mark what is a good and a bad person, or what is to be a “good” or proper women are defined by the patriarchy, and then women are constricted by the rules that men, and thus society, have created. As Furstnau discusses about Phyllis Rackin “‘Reminders that women were expected to be chaste, silent, and obedient probably occur more frequently in recent scholarship than they did in the literature of Shakespeare’s time;” however, she explains, “the connections between female speech and female sexual transgression are retraced and the anxieties evoked by the possibility of female power are discovered in play after play.”(44). Rackin goes on to discuss the importance of history in literary studies, but that “the historical records of the past are often man-made and shaped by men’s anxieties, desires, and interests.”’ (Furstnau).

Introduction

Posted in Shakespeare's comedies on diciembre 9th, 2012 by pasla

In this paper I will discuss The Taming of the Shrew, The Comedy of Errors and A Midsummer Night’s Dream from a feminist perspective. I will deal with several aspects in the three Shakespeare’s plays that question or stand for the patriarchal hierarchy in the Elizabethan England. The patriarchy is still the backbone of our society nowadays and that is what interests me the most. The first paper I wrote for this course was about  social mobility in Shakespeare’s The Two Gentlemen of Verona. The idea of how theatre legitimates or questions a rigid class system is very interesting. A system like that causes that a great part of the population is helplessly left unprotected. So, if a system like that  can be called into question in any way we should learn how. Today, we live in an aggressive capitalist society which needs to be questioned, and cinema and literature would be perfect means of criticism in the same fashion as Shakespeare’s plays were in the Elizabethan England. In the same manner, feminism argues how the patriarchy objectifies and relegates women to an inferior condition. This would be a similar logic to that of the social criticism; to worry about a part of the population who are left unprotected.

I will discuss some aspects in the plays that could be interpreted as subverting attempts against the gender establishment, and others whose ambiguity could resonate with patriarchal undertones. For instance, an important thematic element in Midsummer Night’s Dream from a feminist point of view would be “male dominance”; the contrast between Theseus’ strict patriarchy in Athens and Oberon’s chaotic world of fairies exposes the rigid society of the Elizabethan England. Also, Katherina’s “taming” in The Taming of the Shrew will be studied as a possible chauvinist symbol for the subjugation of women although the complexity of Shakespeare’s work will hint other interpretations. In The Comedy of Errors, Adriana and Luciana, two sisters, epitomize two different perspectives about marriage in the Elizabethan period and the contrast of both perspectives has some ideological implications. In the last section of the paper, I will draw conclusions about the three plays from a feminist point of view.

Bibliography

Posted in Politics and Literarture on diciembre 8th, 2012 by pasla

Ayres, Harry Morgan. “Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar in the Light of Some Other Version”. PMLA 1910: 183-227

Firchow, Peter. “Wells and Lawrence in Huxley´s Brave New World.” Journal of Modern Literature

5.2 (1976): 260-78. Print.

Encyclopedia Britannica Web. 10 October. 2012 <http://www.britannica.com/>

Foucault, Michel. Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (1995) Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group

Goldstein, Malcolm. “Pope, Sheffield, and Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar”. Modern Language Notes Jan. 1956: 8-10

Huxley, Aldous. 1994.  Brave New World. place of publication[AM55] : Flamingo Modern Classic, 1994.

Huxley, Aldous. “Foreword”. Brave New World. London: Flamingo Modern Classic, 1994.  Print.

Larsen, Peter. M. “Synthetic Myths in Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World: A Note.” English Studies 62.6 (1981): 506-8. Print.

Levi-Strauss, Claude. “The Structural Study of Myth”. The Journal of American Folklore. 68.270 (1955): 428-44. Print.

McLuhan, Marshall. “The Medium is the Message”. Media and Cultural Studies: Key Works. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing Ltd (2006): 107-16. Print.

Meckier, Jerome. “Prepping for Brave New World: Aldous Huxley´s Essays of the 1920s.” Utopian Studies 12.2 (2001): 234-45. Print.

Miller, Alex. International Journal of Socialist Renewal. Mon, 04/28/2008  (http://links.org.au/node/379)

Mommsen, Theodor. El mundo de los Césares. Madrid: Fondo de Cultura y Economía, 2004. Printed

Orwell, George. Nineteen Eighty-Four. London:Penguin, 2008. Printed

Plutarch. Lives of Noble Grecians and Romans (Modern Library Series, Vol. 1) New York: Modern Library, 1992. Printed

Shakespeare, William. Julius Caesar. London: Penguin, 2005. Printed

Suetonius. The Twelve Caesars. London: Penguin, 2004. Printed

Conclusion

Posted in Politics and Literarture on diciembre 8th, 2012 by pasla

As a conclusion, I have considered how influential are aesthetic representations for the society and politics of the time in which they are created and for their respective future.

Firstly, I have discussed whether Huxley in Brave New World was not only a forerunner of post-modernism but also of neoliberalism. The method for this discussion has comprised on the one hand, a comparison between him and other contemporary branches of thinking sharing the negative dialectics doctrine, and on the other hand, an analysis of certain narrative techniques and literary textures used in the novel. In Huxley, this negative dialectics that would be the main reason for his omen of post-modernism, appears to be rooted in contempt towards a class of progressive intellectuals, the naïve utopian socialists, and particularly H.G. Wells. Also, the use of narrative techniques such as the character-construction idea in which John the Savage understands a kind of “universal sensibility” coming from a completely different background just by means of reading Shakespeare is clearly a biased narrative… could William Shakespeare be isolated from the rituals and hierarchies of our society?  When a category is universalized and isolated from the background where it has been created, it gets dangerously marked ideologically speaking because what is not included in this universal definition is neglected (e.g. particularities, differences… being black or woman in certain cultures). As a conclusion, several differences between Brave New World’s ideology and some from other groups of thinkers by that time, like Frankfurt School, and also, the use of certain narratives based on biased definitions of ‘human nature’, have shown the very cynical point of view in Brave New World about a state’s regulations. Huxley focus his criticism a lot more on socialism than on capitalism. To sum up, it has been discussed how Huxley makes use of certain institutionalized conventions, like marked narrative devices or ideological discourses, to criticise state interventionism in a clear attempt to distort politics. He does it in a very similar way in which media does it nowadays, with a relentless discourse of cynicism and populism; Neo-liberalism. All these manichean energies stand for his resentment towards socialism and for an incipient neoliberalism.

Secondly, it has been discussed how Orwell’s 1984 criticizes Stalinist communism and the way it neglected the individual. In 1984’s London, a totalitarian dictatorship under the authority of the Big Brother tries that the control over the individual attains the extreme; the control of the unconscious, of ‘what we are in essence’. The alienation of our own self from our own self is reached by means of standardization and
fragmentation of the psyche. Newspeak and torture are the methods of such bizarre society. With such narrative of the individualism, Orwell criticized the U.S.S.R. communism in Stalin’s times.

Thirdly, it has also been discussed how Shakespeare tried to make motor of the history individual actions of emblematic characters instead of bigger social movements. Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar is an idealised character that epitomises the big ideals of the Elizabethan monarchy. In the theatre, audiences witnessed how the danger in a great social system such as their monarchy, in which the leader has no heir (Julius Caesar in the play, and Elisabeth in the real life), is that this leader is murdered and chaos overcomes. This idealizing logic is a perfect narrative in order to legitimize and perpetuate the monarchy. In this kind of narratives, a ‘superior’ class of human beings that makes big sacrifices, dies in the name of others, and that is beyond the human tragedy of having to go to work, waiting a whole month to get salary and pay the rent (Julius Caesar said that he was a descendent of Venus, the goddess (Suetonius 133)), is the perfect symbol for a personality such as the queen Elizabeth.

The conclusion is that literature, and particularly authors such as Huxley, Orwell and Shakespeare, they definitely have the power to bring in ideology among audiences or to expose how institutions really work denouncing injustice this way, without necessarily being killed for their bold ideas. In this manner, Literature can influence social changes, help to overthrow tyrants or work as propaganda to legitimize systems of values.

“Propaganda” to legitimize the Elizabethan monarchy in Julius Caesar

Posted in Politics and Literarture on diciembre 8th, 2012 by pasla

The Traits of a Great Ruler

Several issues were developed by Shakespeare on the basis of certain similarities between the lives of the two rulers (tyrants); Julius Caesar and the Queen Elisabeth, although some of them were stretched Julius Caesar´s traits in order to fit the proper model:
1. Lack of succession
2. The portrayal of a leader who epitomizes the good values of a monarch
3. The magnanimity of a monarch; an “emperor” who renounces to the crown

1. Lack of Succession

The same way and with the same purpose that Plutarch looked for parallelisms between Alexander the Great and Julius Caesar, Shakespeare looked for connections between the lives of  Julius Caesar and Queen Elisabeth, and one of the most significant was the lack of succession. In the beginning of the play, Shakespeare already establishes the fact that Calpurnia, wife of the first man of Rome cannot give birth a heir for Caesar. In the first act, scene two of the play, Caesar despises his wife in the Lupercalia; Roman holidays in which sterile women could recover the possibility of conceiving babies by being hit in the hands with hairy straps of dead animals by young patricians. In Shakespeare´s play, Marc Antony is the patrician called by Caesar in order to make the errand (Plutarch 242). Here, the end of a dynasty, a serious concern in Elizabethan times is clearly presented in the play. The monarchism should prevail, a ruling system with its hierarchy and morals. Moreover, In order to fulfill the narrative according to Elizabethan monarchy, the playwright omits the son Caesar has with Cleopatra; Cesarion (Plutarch 230). Caesar was married with two woman, Calpurnia and Cleopatra, and that was not acceptable neither in Rome nor in England. Shakespeare´s manipulation of Caesar’s figure is clearly seen this way; he silences the data he thinks is necessary to omit in order to fit his purposes; Shakespeare’s myth of Caesar.

2. The Portrayal of a Leader who Epitomizes the Good Values of a Monarch

The portrayal of a leader who epitomizes the good values of a king and who is under the threat of conspiracy reinforces the system of beliefs and dominant ideology in a society like the Elizabethan, one uncertain of its future. The conspiracy of the Optimates (Cassius, Casca and then, Brutus) represents the possible attempt to take over the power by English aristocrats who after the death of the heir-less monarch could reclaim privileges. These Optimates are depicted as ambitious conspirators (all of them except for Brutus who benefits from a better treatment standing for more idealistic values), attributes those of villains in the eyes of Elizabethan England audiences. This way, the play perpetuates Elizabethan system of values in which the monarch´s attributes represent virtues and the aristocratic ones, vices.

3. The Magnanimity of a Monarch; an “Emperor” Who Renounces to the Crown

The idea of Caesar being offered the crown to be a king is a great image to mystify and to show the magnanimity and pride of figures such as powerful rulers. Marc Antony offers him the crown three times and three times Caesar refuses it although every time Caesar shows less reluctance, from Casca viewpoint of course:

Antony offer him a crown;–yet ’twas not a crown
neither, ’twas one of these coronets;–and, as I told
you, he put it by once: but, for all that, to my
thinking, he would fain have had it. Then he
offered it to him again; then he put it by again:
but, to my thinking, he was very loath to lay his
fingers off it. And then he offered it the third
time; he put it the third time by: and still as he
refused it, the rabblement hooted and clapped their
chapped hands and threw up their sweaty night-caps
and uttered such a deal of stinking breath because
Caesar refused the crown that it had almost choked
(Act 2 scene 2 Shakespeare: Julius Caesar)
This shows Caesar magnanimity but his human side (pride) at the same time, trait by means of which audiences would reflect upon. Concerning Shakespeare’s historical accuracy when describing facts and customs such as Caesar being offered the crown, it can be argued that it depends on the historical sources he uses. He is mainly concerned with Plutarch’s work. In Mankiewicz Film, adaptation of the play, the first scene when Caesar is heading for the Lupercalia he is followed by the army and it is a historical fact that the army was not allowed to enter the city, which ia an inaccuracy. However, it does not convey the same authoritative image to portray a ruler surrounded by just family and senators than by those and the army. Anyway, the moment in which Caesar has been offered the crown seems as a detonator for the conspirators to start their plot; the assassination of Caesar.

Bruto and Marc Antony… Political Discourses

The climax of the play is the scene right after Julius Caesar assassination, the moment in which two of the main characters, first Brutus and then Marc Antony, talk to the masses using rhetoric in order to attack, the former, and praise, the latter, Caesar and the myth surrounding him. In the case of Mark Antony, he wants to move the masses against the conspirator´s new rule and keep the old system alive. Both speakers make use of antithetic speeches appealing common sense by means of irony. First Bruto, whose idea is to praise Caesar but Rome more… he “did not love Caesar less but he loved Rome more” (act). With this antithetic logic, Brutus achieves a mood of compassion difficult to avoid. He admits the idea of the “big man” but sees the even more magnificent greatness of a whole hegemonic culture, civilization; the idea of Rome. On the contrary, Mark Antony makes use of an antithetic logic in his speech in order to mock aristocratic values (Boni); he says that Julius Caesar was a great man but since the conspirators were Optimates (aristocrats) and consequently, they are “honorable men”, they must have been right. Marc Antony clearly mocks the aristocratic system of values by means of irony. Moreover, Antony appeals to emotion; first, the time he appears in public (by the end of Brutus speech) he does it in a very shocking way, with Caesar’s dead body in his arms (a graphic image which speaks for itself). One thing is talking about a crime and other very different, seeing the dead body of a victim.
Secondly, while affected after having talk about “the honorable men” in order to expose the crime, he says that he cannot put together more words since his heart is there where the dead body of Caesar lies. A very cold-minded move because “he cannot talk” but he can think of such a “lyrical image” and move the hearts in the masses which are not trained in rhetoric and get easily intoxicated with sentimental devices. The last of these emotional interventions is the moment in which he is going to read the Caesar´s will, in which obviously he bequeaths the people of Rome everything he has being a heirless “emperor”, Antoni uncovers Caesar body by pulling the tunic and gives his last words over a stabbed body, the body of a powerful man reduced to a piece of flesh. Marc Antoni gives an image of humanity and sublimity difficult to reject… the image that monarchy needed to reinforce in Elizabethan England.

 

Nineteen Eighty-Four’s criticism of Stalin’s communism

Posted in Politics and Literarture on diciembre 8th, 2012 by pasla

1. Nineteen Eighty-Four: The Fragmentation of the Individual

George Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four foreshadows a future in which a totalitarian dictatorship controls the life of the citizens to a extent in which there is no place for privacy anymore. The story of Winston Smith, an individual,  in a London ruled by the Big Brother, and in which there is only a unique political party, can be interpreted as a criticism of a totalitarian regime, and in particular Stalin’s communism. Also, given the, coercive or not, control over the citizens nowadays with the internet, the novel has a new significance. Nineteen Eighty-Four represents a nightmarish vision in which a totalitarian society takes over its members’ psyche. The omnipresent Big Brother (whose existence is undeniable but impossible to prove at the same time), the thought police, the Newspeak (creation and imposition of a language by means of which nothing can be thought of), the fearful thoughtcrime, and the existence of four ministries (Peace, Plenty, Love, Truth) are the mechanism that allows the control over people. People do not know about neither the intimacy nor freethought and sexual pleasure is forbidden for them. Winston Smith is part of a group that is against this order of things, However, Big Brother will success in the end. One of the most significant places in the story is the Ministry of Truth, where Smith is a worker. They re-write the history there by using the means of communication. That is fundamental in Nineteen Eighty-Four since “who controls the past controls the future. Who controls the present controls the past” (Orwell 37). By its torrent of signification, society tries to give expression to means of representation, of feeling, of acting but also, of repression. This torrent is heterogeneous because society is divided in classes and strata. In order to be introduced, new elements must go through modifications imposed by the psyche: work of what we call radical imagination (Foucault 43). This way, individuals can keep different kinds of relationships with the established world or another, relationships which range from alienation to autonomy; the mixed ones are the most frequent. Orwell’s novel takes it to the extreme of standardization and fragmentation of the psyche, while pretending it to be absolute without remainder, I mean, neglecting the unconscious of the individuals and starting on their imagination. This way of fragmenting the individual is carried out as much by physical means (torture), as psychological (Newspeak).

“Do not imagine that you will save yourself, Winston, however completely you surrender to us. No one who has once gone astray is ever spared. And even if we chose to let you live out the natural term of your life, still, you would never escape from us. What happens to you here is forever. Understand that in advance. We shall crush you down to the point from which there is no coming back . Things will happen to you from which you could not recover, if you lived a thousand years. Never again will you be capable of ordinary human feeling. Everything will be dead inside you. Never again will you be capable of love, or friendship, or joy of living, or laughter, or curiosity, or courage, or integrity. You will be hollow. We shall squeeze new empty, and then we shall fill you with ourselves.” (Orwell )

2. Nineteen Eighty-Four: Marx vs Orwell

I will also use an article by Alex Miller (Links: International journal of Socialist Renewal) that deals with the differences between Karl Marx ideology and the much more elitist Orwell’s position. Orwell thought that lower classes (working classes) were ignorant and enabled them for a revolution. This could be the reason why he uses a narrative of individualism (a bourgase narrative) to criticise communism, as he did not find another way to react against a tyranny but by means of individualism:
“Bound to Degenerate (by Alex Miller)”
“Thus, Orwell’s elitist and patronising attitude towards the working class in Animal Farm reappears in Nineteen Eighty-Four, and the headline message is the same: a socialist revolution, even if it were to happen in an advanced capitalist country, would be bound to degenerate because of the innate helplessness and lack of intelligence of the working class. It is worth noting in passing that Marx himself, despite being an infinitely better writer and thinker than Orwell, had an entirely different attitude towards ordinary people. He wrote, for example:

When the communist artisans meet, they seem to be meeting for the purpose of propaganda, etc. But in the process they acquire a new need, the need for society, and what seemed to be a means has become an end in itself. One can see the most illuminating effects of this practical process if one watches a meeting of socialist French workers. Smoking, drinking and eating are no longer merely an excuse for meeting. The society, the entertainment, which is supposed to be for the purpose of meeting, is sufficient in itself: the brotherhood of Man is no idle phrase but the real truth, and the nobility of Man shines out at us from these faces brutalized by toil (quoted in Werner Blumenberg, Karl Marx: An Illustrated History, Verso 2000, p.47).

And there are deeper differences between Orwell and Marx. Orwell believes that power, independently of the specific social circumstances in which it is realised, is governed by a logic that inevitably leads to corruption and exploitation. In his view, even if the working-class successfully seizes power in an advanced capitalist country, corruption and exploitation will inevitably prevail. This idealist and anarchist philosophy is vastly inferior to Marx’s approach, according to which power can only be studied meaningfully as embodied in concrete social and economic structures.
This point is well-made by Deutscher: “at heart Orwell was a simple-minded anarchist … To analyse a complicated social background, to try and unravel tangles of political motives, calculations, fears and suspicions, and to discern the compulsion of circumstances behind their action was beyond him. Generalisations about social forces, social trends, and historic inevitabilities made him bristle with suspicion … Yet his distrust of historical generalisations led him in the end to adopt and to cling to the oldest, the most banal, the most abstract, the most metaphysical, and the most barren of all generalisations: all their conspiracies and plots and purges had one source and one source only – ‘sadistic power hunger’. Thus he made his jump from workaday, rationalistic common sense to the mysticism of cruelty which inspires 1984” (Heretics and Renegades, pp.47-8).
Our conclusion is thus that given an understanding of the social and economic factors that led to the degeneration of the Russian Revolution, neither Animal Farm nor Nineteen Eighty-Four give us compelling reason to believe that a socialist revolution in an advanced capitalist society must inevitably deteriorate into Stalinism, or worse. Thus, despite whatever other literary merits they may possess, neither of Orwell’s most famous books constitutes an effective critique of Stalinism `from the left’.” (Alex Miller)