Social Mobility in The Two Gentlemen of Verona; a Powerful Duke Wants More Power and a Poor Servant Accepts Receiving a Beating in the Place of his Dog

Posted in Shakespeare's Two Gentlemen of Verona on octubre 12th, 2012 by pasla

The class system is subverted over and over again in the play. On the one hand, The Duke wants his daughter to marry Thurio since the later is a wealthier man and this union would mean social promotion for the Duke. On the other hand, Launce assumes the responsibility of Crab´s «piss», his dog´s, on the Duke´s room. He loves his dog so much that he claims to have urinated himself on the Duke´s bed and takes the beating in the place of the dog. This inversion of owner and possession (pet), must have been outrageous in Elizabethan England were social mobility was so difficult. Also, there is the forest where any societal norm has no value. There, Elizabethan system of values is subverted in its entire form, and, imagination and difference are awarded grating Valentine the status of leader of outcasts.
Ironically, a powerful Duke wants more power and a poor servant accepts to receive a beating in the place of his dog. Also, the forest is a symbol of Shakespeare´s youth, where he lived back in his early years Stratffor-upon-avon, and opposed to London it is a freer environment where the rigid system of values of Elizabethan society does not work. This confrontation of ideas, exposes the logic behind Elizabethan morals and it consequences where the greedy wants more if he has a choice, the poor does not have many things and he is able to defend them, the few things he has, with his life if he has the choice. Also, the hideouts like forests and more rural areas outside the city are haven for the ones who runaway from social rigidity.

Tags:

Launce: The More “Realistic” Side of Romantic Love

Posted in Shakespeare's Two Gentlemen of Verona on octubre 12th, 2012 by pasla

Launce gives the more «realistic» side of romantic love, seemingly the voice of the author on the matter (Servants are the voice of the author´s irony and intelligence). He speaks in prose, typical language in Shakespeare´s early plays for lower classes (which would mean a great a modernization in some time). First, Romantic love belongs to high classes, which are eternal kids ignorant of earthly worries and needs. Launce talks of his beloved as someone who knows how to work, who is somehow useful to him but who gives him pleasure and good moments too. It is neither a too idealistic nor, on the other hand, too utilitarian point of view. However, Launce will be able to stand for his dog, Crab, in a way that will question the integrity of Elizabethan system.

Tags:

Proteus: The Dark side, More Machiavellian One, of Romantic Love

Posted in Shakespeare's Two Gentlemen of Verona on octubre 12th, 2012 by pasla

Proteus stands for the dark side, more Machiavellian one, of romantic love. Whim and lust are the motor of his transgression. His obsession mirrors that of Valentine but with the sight that disillusionment and a more experienced point of view conveys of such situation. In the guise of tyrant, Proteus whimsically shifts his love from Julia to Silvia, the Duke´s daughter. Other attempt of social promotion, in this case motivated by whim, and after what has been said about the rigid Elizabethan social strata another improbable one. This is another subversion of such system and this time with the negative connotation it carries; the tyrant traits: Proteus is not just subverting the class system but every societal good value like friendship, faithfulness and so on to be forgiven in the end by his deceived friend, Valentine. Shakespeare cosmos does not punish his transgression in the end. Some critics say that this is owed to Shakespeare´s Catholic beliefs as a pardon for Proteus confession (Hunt 12) but the fact is that he is not finally punished. Here, the attempt to subvert Elisabethan rigid class system is forgiven by Shakespeare and this could mean that Shakespeare’s aesthetics are part of the ideological construct that it was discussed while talking about Valentine.

Tags:

Valentine: The Idealistic, Sunny Aspect of Romantic Love

Posted in Shakespeare's Two Gentlemen of Verona on octubre 12th, 2012 by pasla

Valentine shows the idealistic, sunny aspect of it. Every society needs an ideological apparatus in order to legitimate the values which constitute it. This, so to say, «propaganda» is conveyed by certain ideological devices in media like theater (theater was the most popular media in Elizabethan England). This way, romantic love mechanics are one of those stylistic devices in which like Adorno and Horkheimer say about culture industry «Style represents a promise in every work of art. That which is expressed is subsumed through style into the dominant forms of generality, into the language of music, painting, or words, in the hope that it will be reconciled thus with the idea of true generality. This promise held out by the work of art that it will create truth by lending new shape to the conventional social forms is as necessary as it is hypocritical. It unconditionally posits the real forms of life as it is by suggesting that fulfilment lies in their aesthetic derivatives. To this extent the claim of art is always ideology too» (Adorno, Horkheimer) a promise of something better is conveyed to audiences, an anxiety very proper in order to tame and indoctrinate the population. In spite of the ending where some critics have interpreted certain homosexual tension the moment in which Valentine seems to offer his beloved Silvia to his friend Proteus, Valentine stands for the idealistic aspect of romantic love. He wants to elope with Silvia and escape social restrictions this way, not a very realistic idea given the rigidity of Elizabethan society controlled by means of the Sumptuary laws, and of course,  the consequent mindset of that time. The reason why the play is not located in England and it is in Italy could be this; it would be too subversive to portray such straightforward violation of English values. Besides, in the Renaissance times, Italy was a source of inspiration and a place for great histories and heroes inspired in classic Greek and Roman myths. This Way Shakespeare writes about English society, and how to subvert certain conventions without running the risk of being prosecuted.

Tags:

Romantic Love Subverts the Rigid Elizabethan Class System

Posted in Shakespeare's Two Gentlemen of Verona on octubre 12th, 2012 by pasla

Three different aspects of romantic love are presented by means of three characters; Valentine, Proteus and Launce. Each of those characters try to subvert the Elizabethan rigid class system by means of their three different conceptions of romantic love:

Valentine; the idealistic, sunny aspect of romantic love.

Proteus; the dark side, more Machiavellian one, of romantic love.

Launce; the more «realistic» side of romantic love.

Tags:

Introduction: Shakespeare´s Julius Caesar… Political Discourse

Posted in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar on octubre 12th, 2012 by pasla

In this paper, I will discuss William Shakespeare’s play, Julius Caesar, and how the playwright makes use of Caesar’s myth in order to perpetuate Monarchism in Elizabethan England. Shakespeare worked for the queen and became the most successful playwright of his time. In the ideological struggle to stand for the monarchy, theater and its political machinery were essential in the «propaganda» for the totalitarian system to prevail. Since in Elizabethan England there was great fear of turmoil because of what had happened after the War of the Roses (the Tudor) and queen Elisabeth being in her sixties and without succession, Shakespeare played an important role working with historical myths such as Julius Caesar’s in supporting the monarchic ideology.

Tags:

5. Fifth Stage

Posted in Kendall-> 2. Tools _5. Fifth Stage on enero 13th, 2010 by pasla

And in the fifth stage, the final one, we see all the words on screen fall to the ground like rain. Everything falls, empiricism, facts, events, people…even Faith, being all part of human life. The only left is: “To sum up with”, which shows us the final conclusion… everything falls, everything is the same… human creation. And let us the option to repeat the experience, like a close circle, like circle life… from human´s point of view.

4. Fourth Stage

Posted in Kendall-> 2. Tools _4. Fourth Stage on enero 13th, 2010 by pasla

On the fourth stage the author keeps on working on the same level as on the stage before. The perturbing music keeps on evoking certain feeling of terror, and takes us to some places in our mind where is difficult to look at. But this time the interaction of letters and music is different, some new words appear and some loose colour-strength. This time the mixture turns into a not so dark scene (to say it one way …it turns from Blade Runner to Steven Spielberg’s Close encounters on the third kind). And the stage ends with a word full of meaning that sliding comes to us and almost slaps our faces: LEAP. This is when a word in the poem is again full of meaning, and we lose this global interaction we were talking about. From my point of view this word, “LEAP”, hides the meaning of the whole idea, of the whole poem; an act of faith is like leaping, like a jump. You have to jump into the unknown, when you believe that there´s something there without any empirical proof of it… and you jump just because you believe there is something else you cannot see, that leap or jump is the perfect image of Faith (a leap of faith).

3. Third Stage

Posted in Kendall-> 2. Tools _3. Third Stage on enero 13th, 2010 by pasla

From certain point of view the third stage is the culmination of this expression, of this language so well used by the poet…   where tools are at complete service of poetry. The meaning of the words is not so obvious and the mixture of textures: music, movement, graphics, colours and the words themselves is so powerful that you can really feel the effect of this medium, Electronic poetry. Here the poetry is in the whole expression and not isolated in words. From my point of view is a very strong moment and it is given by this kind of Avant-Garde feeling consequence of this execution we have been talking about. The music here is different, we could say that the evoking sound is in some ways emulating a church organ, but I would say that the perturbing atonal melody of the synthesizer sounds as the soundtrack of an apocalyptical science-fiction movie… e.g. Ridley Scott´s Blade Runner.

This time the letters move with a lot more freedom, and we see some of these movements so full of meaning… e.g.  the words “red winking neon” fall diagonally in one moment, as if they were an old neon-light, and start blinking a half broken down. Or the word “theory” spins round and round in a very ironical motion-picture. On the other hand the letters appear now in very different ways, ones sliding, others coming from nowhere and others falling.

2. Second Stage

Posted in Kendall-> 2. Tools _2. Second Stage on enero 13th, 2010 by pasla

On the second stage, with the same kind of harp sound, in different colour than before (before the letters were yellow and now red) more letters appear but this time with some kind of order, sliding and coming from the sides. Of course the music this time more melodic to go with the less chaotic movement of the letters.  The idea the new message brings with this kind of random movement of shapes, is one on a existentialism style…with this: “edge the logic out. Can´t the mind press on, around the bend, to consummate this vision of the deep “or”?” Nietzsche-like thought.